Sunday, April 19, 2009

Where are the jobs?

The unemployment rate in USA is now at 8.5% and is expected to increase to 10%. The unemployment rate in many countries Europe has been over 10% for many years. 

The unemployment rate in Singapore may appear low by international standards, but it is seriously under-reported. Due to the lack of employment benefit, many people do not bother to report that they are looking for work.

Minister of Manpower Gan Kim Yong advised graduates to take any job, rather than sit at home. But, where are the jobs? There are insufficient jobs for the large number of people looking for work. Those with jobs work long hours, to justify their cost to the employer. This is the outcome of the free market system.

If we continue to believe in the free market and in globalisation, it will take a long time for a solution to be found. The free market system has finally broken down, and yet economists and  policymakers do not want to face the reality that it is a failed system.

We need a better system (other than the free market) to distribute the work among the people in the world in a fair manner. This will give a better quality of life to all people. 

Tan Kin Lian

Bonus cut on life insurance policies

Dear Mr. Tan,
I received a letter fror my insurance company that they are cutting my bonus. I know that the global economic situation is bad, but I feel that there is no need for a big cut. After all, the insurance company made big profit last year, and they did not increase their bonus rate by much. Is it fair?

REPLY
I agree with your views. There is lack of transparency in the manner in which the bonus has been cut. Some policies have a bigger cut in bonus compared to other policies. It seems that the old plans have bigger cut compared to the newer plans, as the insurance company hopes to sell their new plans. 

It is important that insurance companies should treat all policyholders fairly and that the bonus must be distributed fairly based on the actual experience of the insurance fund. It is not fair for an insurance company to withhold profits in good years and make a big cut in bad years.

If you wish to provide feedback on the bonus cut on your policy, you can give details here. It will be kept in confidence.


Saturday, April 18, 2009

Survey: Getting our young into Politics

Mr. Lee Kuan Yew said that young people are not interested to go into politics. He quoted the example of his grandson, who is now on a scholarship.

I like to carry out this survey to get the views of a wider group of people. Please participate.

Here are the survey results.

Financial Advisory Approach

Contributed by Zhummmeng

A financial advisory approach is entirely different from product pushing.  The advisory approach aims to put the interest of the clients first and to address the cleints' interest on a reasonable basis.Products are solutions.It is assumed that the advisers have no inkling of the product suitable for the clients until the clients' needs are uncovered.

The product pushing approach is aimed at selling the products with the highest commission that benefit the salesmen and NOT the clients.It is peddling the products upfront. It is fast and quick way of making money for the insurance salesmen. All MDRT, COT or TOT aspirants use this method and to make a lot of commission to qualify for these dubious awards because it is commission based.MAS must address this if it wants to see a fair dealing outcome for consumers.

In an advisory process it begins with gathering of data , needs, goals fears and concerns of the clients, financial circumstances, preferences etc and then followed by analysis and then recommendation and implementation of the recommendations or executions and monitoring.

The advisory is a 6 step approach:
1.Establishment of relationship between client and adviser, defination of goals and objectives 
2.data gathering.
3.Analysis
4.Recommendations/a plan constructed
5.Implementation
6. Monitoring and review

The whole process is documented in the fact find form, from analysis to recommendation and reasons of recommendation..This plan is portable and can be reviewed by another adviser to continue the advisory work if the client wants a change of adviser.

So, you see, the whole process isn't what the insurance agents are doing. Do you think your needs can be settled within an hour? Sure, your "needs" will be short changed if you are product sold. Not only that, you are likely to be mis-sold ,misrepresented all because of the greed or incompetence of the insurance agents. It is very clear insurance agents pushing products have no desire to help the clients meet their goals.

To solve this problem.
1. Make the advisory need based approach compulsory for most if not all cases. Who needs this most? The ordinary man in the street needs this help. They are clueless, ignorant and not financially savvy. Usually these people make up the major clientele of any adviser and not the rich or savvy who don't need advice.
2. Make all advisers or insurance agents accountable and liable for their recommendations. This is to prevent product pushing and malpractice.
3. Remove the commission and replace with fee . (commission is the major cause of mis-selling and conflict of interest)
4.  Set a review body to help clients review their existing policies for mis-selling or conflict of interest and inappropriate recommendations.
5. A product advice or no advice WARNING to savvy clients. A warning must be verbally told to client and stated in the fact find form that choosing the options of 'product advice' and 'no advice' will put them at a disadvantage and by their action their rights to redress will be forfeited and waived if the product bought is wrong.

This is necessary to prevent abuse by insurance agents who try to avoid fact finding or to decieve the cleints that fact find is inconveneint to them and messy. This is also to stop the insurance agents from short changing the clients.Currently it seems that insurance agents' clients are financially savvy.The fact it is the opposite. All clients must be assumed to be clueless in order for a proper process to take place.

Zhummmeng

Thursday, April 16, 2009

Speak out for others

Article printed in The Online Citizen

Survey - Sale and marketing of unlisted investment products

The protem committee of FISCA (Financial Services Consumer Association) intends to submit the following paper to MAS giving our views on its proposals regarding the sale and marketing of unlisted investment products (including life insurance and structured products).

Give your views to FISCA's proposals in this survey.

Recession 'fuels insurance fraud'

Report